Guarantee or collateral: which should you offer the bank?
How a public credit guarantee compares with pledging property or giving personal guarantees, and how to combine them to borrow what you need at the lowest risk.

When a bank says “not enough security”, owners usually have three levers: pledge more assets, sign more personal guarantees, or bring in a third-party credit guarantee. They are not mutually exclusive, and the best answer is usually a combination. Here is how they compare.
The options side by side
| More collateral | Personal guarantee | Credit guarantee (e.g. ALTUM) | |
|---|---|---|---|
| What you give | A mortgage or pledge on business or personal assets | Your personal promise to pay | A fee |
| Cost | Valuation, notary, registration, insurance | None directly | Annual premium on the guaranteed amount |
| Risk to owners | Loss of the pledged asset | All personal assets, up to the cap | None beyond the business, unless you also sign personal guarantees |
| Effect on bank | Lower loss if default | Strong incentive signal, value depends on your wealth | Guarantor covers up to 80% of the loss on the guaranteed principal |
| Speed | Valuation and registration take time | Fast | Adds a decision by the guarantor |
| State aid | No | No | Yes, counts towards de minimis or other limits |
When collateral is the better choice
- The business owns unencumbered real estate with a solid value.
- You have already used much of your de minimis allowance, so a guarantee would block other support.
- The loan is small and a guarantee’s fixed costs and paperwork are disproportionate.
When a credit guarantee is the better choice
- The company’s assets are specialised or already pledged.
- Pledging would mean putting personal or family property at risk.
- You want a longer term than the bank would accept on collateral alone.
- The business is young or service-based with few assets.
Combining them well
A typical structure for a €400,000 investment loan:
- Commercial pledge on the equipment being purchased.
- Mortgage on the company’s existing premises.
- ALTUM guarantee covering a share of the principal to bridge the remaining gap.
- Personal guarantee from the main owner, capped at a modest amount.
Each layer reduces the bank’s risk a little. The aim is to cover the bank’s concerns without putting more of your personal wealth at stake than necessary.
Negotiating points
- If a guarantee covers a large share of the loan, ask the bank to reduce or cap the personal guarantee.
- Ask whether the guarantee allows a lower margin, since the bank’s risk is lower.
- Ask how collateral proceeds are shared between the bank and the guarantor in a default, because this affects how much the bank will still want from you.
See also collateral for business loans and personal guarantees.
Questions people ask
Will a guarantee replace all collateral?
Rarely. Banks normally still take security over the financed assets and often a personal guarantee. The guarantee covers the gap between what that security is worth and what you need to borrow.
Is it better to pledge my house than pay a guarantee fee?
Financially the pledge may be cheaper, but it puts the family's home at risk if the business fails. Many owners prefer to pay the fee and keep personal assets separate. It is a risk decision, not only a cost decision.